Explore the Map|United States/New Jersey/
Middletown
Fishing In

Middletown, New Jersey

With FishAngler you can discover the best fishing spots in Middletown. Check out the top fish species being caught and learn what baits are the most successful. Get detailed information on when and where the fish are biting in Middletown and get valuable tips to increase your fishing success.
40.411305, -74.063892

Top Fish Species In Middletown, New Jersey

Bluefish
32 Catches
Summer flounder
25 Catches
Striped bass
22 Catches
Spot croaker
12 Catches
Dusky smooth-hound
8 Catches
Largemouth black bass
7 Catches
Southern flounder
5 Catches
Atlantic croaker
5 Catches
Striped searobin
4 Catches
Bluegill
3 Catches
Sandbar shark
3 Catches
American gizzard shad
2 Catches

Recent Catches In Middletown, New Jersey

PapiCaine NJ At Sandy Hook Bay

1 week ago
 • 
Monmouth County, New Jersey

Atlantic croaker
2
12 likes

PapiCaine NJ At Sandy Hook Bay

1 week ago
 • 
Monmouth County, New Jersey

Atlantic croaker
2
10 likes

PapiCaine NJ At Sandy Hook Bay

1 week ago
 • 
Monmouth County, New Jersey

Atlantic croaker
2
11 likes

PapiCaine NJ At Sandy Hook Bay

1 week ago
 • 
Monmouth County, New Jersey

Atlantic croaker
2
9 likes

Mark Motichka At Church Street Park Pond

2 weeks ago
 • 
Monmouth County, New Jersey

Bluegill
4 likes

Mark Motichka At Shadow Lake

2 weeks ago
 • 
Monmouth County, New Jersey

Bread and bobber never fails when u had a rough day

Bluegill
3 likes

Mark Motichka At Shadow Lake

2 weeks ago
 • 
Monmouth County, New Jersey

Used as live bait and got ripped off 😔

American gizzard shad
3 likes • 1 comment

Mark Motichka At Unnamed / Brandywine Way Pond

2 weeks ago
 • 
Monmouth County, New Jersey

Bluegill
4 likes
Want to see more catches in
Middletown, New Jersey

Popular Fishing Spots In Middletown, New Jersey

5.0
(1)
Shadow Lake
Middletown, New Jersey
14 Catches
No Rating (0)
Unnamed / Brandywine Way Pond
Middletown, New Jersey
4 Catches
No Rating (0)
North Pond
Middletown, New Jersey
2 Catches
No Rating (0)
Church Street Park Pond
Middletown, New Jersey
1 Catch
No Rating (0)
Unnamed / Sleepy Hollow Rd Pond
Middletown, New Jersey
1 Catch
No Rating (0)
Haskell Pond
Middletown, New Jersey
No Rating (0)
Marion Lake
Middletown, New Jersey
No Rating (0)
Navesink River Road Dam
Middletown, New Jersey
Want to see more fishing spots in
Middletown, New Jersey

Other Cities Near Middletown

Belford
Monmouth County, New Jersey
Fort Hancock
Monmouth County, New Jersey
Atlantic Highlands
Monmouth County, New Jersey
Fairview
Monmouth County, New Jersey
Fair Haven
Monmouth County, New Jersey
Harmony
Monmouth County, New Jersey
East Keansburg
Monmouth County, New Jersey
Fort Monmouth
Monmouth County, New Jersey
Blue background image
App image
Want to know more about fishing in or around
Middletown?
Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all the intel you need to catch more fish!
QR
Apple Store Google Play Store
Rating App Reviews