Fishing At

Horseshoe Lake

5.0

(2)

9 Catches

Horseshoe Lake is located in Sullivan County, New York. Download FishAngler to find the best places to fish at Horseshoe Lake. Get local fishing reports with detailed catch information, weather conditions, top baits and more.

41.740435, -74.830947

Explore Full Map

Recent Catches At Horseshoe Lake

Lawrence Card

2023-06-06

•

Sullivan County, New York

Species Largemouth black bass

3 likes

Lawrence Card

2023-06-03

•

Sullivan County, New York

Species Redear sunfish

10 likes

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Lawrence Card

2023-06-03

•

Sullivan County, New York

Species Largemouth black bass

12 likes

Brandon Golzak

2022-07-16

•

Sullivan County, New York

#Catch22

10 likes

Brandon Golzak

2022-07-16

•

Sullivan County, New York

#Catch22

Species Grass pickerel

10 likes

Brandon Golzak

2022-07-16

•

Sullivan County, New York

#catch22

6 likes

Lawrence Card

2022-06-11

•

Sullivan County, New York

Nice fight on this one beautiful sunset sky.

Species Largemouth black bass

Gear 1

15 likes

Lawrence Card

2022-06-11

•

Sullivan County, New York

Great night to be on the lake.

Gear 1

5 likes

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Most Caught Fish Species At Horseshoe Lake

Largemouth black bass

Popular Fishing Spots Near Horseshoe Lake

Lake Wallenpaupack

26.6 mi away • Pike County, Pennsylvania

11.3 mi away • Orange County, New York

43.6 mi away • Dutchess County, New York

Susquehanna River

33.5 mi away • Otsego County, New York

Cannonsville Reservoir

30.3 mi away • Delaware County, New York

36.6 mi away • Ulster County, New York

New Wawayanda Lake

49.6 mi away • Andover, New Jersey

Winding Hills Park Lake

31.8 mi away • Orange County, New York

Blue background image

App image

Want to know more about fishing at

Horseshoe Lake?

Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all the intel you need to catch more fish!